Rubio “Co-Op” Rare Earth Elements Bill Is A Pipe Dream

US bill calls for all-American effort to boost rare-earth supply

Following the recent announcement about US efforts to win support for a cooperative type model for production of rare earth elements, has fielded inquiries and comments from around the world. While the Rubio bill is patriot, ambitious and much needed, the cooperative concept could be a non-starter. While it will be helpful to see relaxed mining permits and other government help, the sheer investment and infrastructure required for an effort is vast. As time passes, the world will learn whether this effort is rhetoric or something with real potential. We plan to visit with Rubio’s staff and dig deeply into details about the proposed plan. More details about the story are contained below.

Sen. Rubio suggests establishing ‘cooperative’ to combat China monopolyALEX FANG, Nikkei staff writer

A front-end loader is seen at California’s Molycorp’s Mountain Pass Rare Earth facility. China’s threat to restrict rare earth exports would cause disruptions across U.S. high-tech supply chains.   © Reuters

NEW YORK — U.S. Republican Sen. Marco Rubio introduced a bill in Congress Thursday to boost the country’s rare-earth industry, in an effort to break American advanced manufacturing’s reliance on importing key metals and compounds from China.

The legislation calls for the establishment of a privately funded and operated cooperative to build a fully integrated domestic rare-earth value chain.

A co-op would bring companies together to keep production costs low, all while enjoying an antitrust exemption. Such a formula will empower American producers to take on Chinese rivals benefiting from state subsidies, Rubio believes.

“We must shift our policies to restore the competitiveness of critical American industries for the 21st century,” Rubio, who is known for his hawkish stand on China, said in a statement Thursday.

“Continued U.S. dependence on China for the mining and processing of rare earths and the manufacture of those metals into useful products is untenable,” Rubio said. “It threatens our national security, limits our economic productivity, and robs working-class Americans of future opportunities for dignified work.”

Senator Marco Rubio, a key congressional hawk on China, wants the U.S. to build its own rare-earth supply chain to “restore American competitiveness of critical advanced manufacturing industries.”   © Reuters

Per the bill, the co-op will produce rare-earth products as needed by its members and is allowed to sell surplus goods to outside buyers. As a cooperative is typically owned and operated directly by those who use its products and services, management has more incentive to improve their quality. Such a model is often used in food and utility industries to add accountability while keeping the supplier private.

“We can’t beat China by playing their game, which is why this bill harnesses the American cooperative model as a time-tested way to correct for failed markets without relying on heavy-handed federal intervention,” Rubio said.

The co-op may receive foreign investment, the bill said, but only upon approval from the Committee on Foreign Investment, which is placing increasing scrutiny on Chinese investment in the U.S.

China produces some 70% of the world’s rare earths, which are critical to manufacturing parts used in products ranging from electric vehicles to military equipment. The U.S. imports 80% of such minerals from the Asian country.

Amid heightened trade tensions between Washington and Beijing, China last month signaled potential restrictions on its rare-earth metal exports, which could cause disruptions across high-tech industries’ supply chains.

To reduce reliance on Chinese rare-earth metals, the U.S. Department of Commerce in June made 61 recommendations — including stockpiling, catalyzing exploration, and relaxing domestic mining regulations.

The production of rare earths, which generate radioactive wastes, has been more difficult in the U.S. than in China, where environmental standards have been relatively lax.

The U.S. reserve of rare earths is 3% of China’s, according to the U.S. Geological Survey.

Please follow and like us:

Hits: 50

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *